iPhunwa | 23 points
[-] [deleted] | 1 points
[deleted]
The note the encoder left for this release said
had pleasure to work on A WATERMARKED ASS C_ _ VIDEO, as usual THE IDIOT WATERMARKED IT BADLY ON MIDDLE,TOP , DOWN , SIDE , LEFT , RIGHT THROUGH OUT THE WHOLE VIDEO ....AND HE MADE A HUGE CRAP.....
I'm assuming he's referring to the CPG release being the one watermarked. Regardless, posted it anyway along with 2 samples - https://redd.it/5iyase
[-] mantriddrone | 2 points
neither of them. the best one out at the moment is
"Rogue.One-A.Star.Wars.Story.2016.HDCAM.AC3.2.0.x264-BDP"
[-] age_of_cage | 1 points
Rogue.One-A.Star.Wars.Story.2016.HDCAM.AC3.2.0.x264-BDP
How does a HDCAM be better than a TS?
[-] mantriddrone | 2 points
i've no idea about the terminology used. i can only attest to the quality of the release.
[-] age_of_cage | 2 points
Well having now reviewed both, I can attest you are dead wrong. Unsurprisingly, the TS is indeed the better version. How you could recommend cam audio over direct line is a mystery to me. That's not even mentioning the Nakro version having better picture too.
If that looks like the UNKNOWN release then I agree. The video is a lot worse on this TS. I don't understand why they didn't take that video and just overdub the new audio. I've compared them too. Whoever did it added all of these stupid filters that ruined the video in the darker scenes. Like some of the space scenes look a lot worse. Haven't previewed the full CPG but thats the case with this one.
The CPG one that is 1.81 GB doesn't look like its watermarked. No mention of it in the info either. I think they redid it and if they did, it looks to be the best one out.
https://extraimage.net/image/2jMY
"Notes: lot of people were saying we should do encode of first source, so here we are. for us its Kind of New. used latino source, crop,resize some usual stuff then smart bright the video, its major issue was noise contant flicker and noise. so first we remove flicker. its 99% gone. then we remove the noise. put some sharp back to video. and unblur certain parts. Now since we used latino source so it was missing subs, so we took the subtitles from our previous release, Rewrite overlay and hardcoded on video. i hope i got them all.. then reSync digital audio to finish encode.
is this better then previous? well it was not BUT Now it is. you people download and enjoy ;) and some should grab their poo bottles and get to blurring work... make sure you don't miss any spot like last time or say good bye to candies!!!!"
Rogue One A Star Wars Story 2016 HDTS x264 AC3-Garmin
Someone finally took the UNKNOWN video source (didn't mess with it a lot) and the TS audio and put them together.
The UNKNOWN source was far from perfect (it's dark in a lot of areas but all of them are) or anything but at least the colors on and there is no frame rate issues.
That is by far the best one out right now and I've seen them all.
Alright the 2.2 GB CPG is better then the 1.81 CGP one but the colors are still off in areas and it goes temporarily out of focus quite a bit which is frustrating. Watchable though.
The best video is still the UNKNOWN HDCAM release. The video of the AC AB TS release would be awesome without the framerate issues.
There are no watermarks other then a slight link that appears everyonce in awhile.
[-] body85 | 2 points | Dec 18 2016 19:15:05
Alright the one I think looks the best so far out of the TS releases is actually the ACAB release. It's a different source then CPG used. It looks more like a screener (VHS) and has sort of choppy framerate in areas which is really annoying. It's also grainy and still too dark frequently but the colors are closer to the actual movie.
Rogue One A Star Wars Story 2016 READNFO TS XviD AC3 ACAB
The 1.81 CPG release is decent (better then the NAKRO) but it still has that annoying filter to try to brighten dark scenes that make it appear white when there's sunlight shining down. The color is off during the entire thing because of it.
Both are watchable but the best video by far is still coming from the UNKNOWN cam.
Going to check out the 2.2 CPG one next.
permalink